English Russian
Izvestiya of Altai State
University Journal
The News of Altai State University

 Архив журнала «Известия АлтГУ», начиная с 2017 г., размещен на новой версии сайта http://izvestiya.asu.ru
 Актуальная информация о журнале размещена на новой версии сайта http://izvestiya.asu.ru

Print ISSN 1561-9443
On-line ISSN 1561-9451
Issues list
Table of Contents
Legal Science
About the Journal
Editorial board and Editorial advisory board
Regulations on reviewing research papers
Rules of the articles representation
Publication Ethics of the journal «Izvestiya of Altai State University»

N.A. Dudko, A.S. Kamnev

Jury Verdict of Acquittal Revisited

This article emphasizes a growing tendency in the RF Criminal Procedure Law to limit the jury trial jurisdiction over criminal cases, to introduce a jury trial appeal, to reduce the number of jurors, and to return the concept of “objective truth”. It also raises concerns about the fact that the proposed legislative changes might prevent the RF citizens from exercising their constitutional right to participate in administering justice. The article reviews the reasons prompting members of the jury to acquit defendants in the most controversial situation when the defendant’s participation in the alleged crime is proved. The article concludes that guilt as a mental attitude of defendants toward what they have wrought and as an element of a crime becomes a category of evaluation rather than a technical one. Discretion of jurors — unlike the one of the professional judges — in determining the defendant’s guilt is not based on mens rea (malice, negligence). The decision is rather based on the social harm of an alleged crime, on its compliance with the ethics and morals of the society. This enables us to make a conclusion that the jury sentencing discretion in determining the defendant’s guilt is more flexible than the one of professional judges and this cannot be a reason for criticism of jury system, since it is its major advantage.

DOI 10.14258/izvasu(2015)2.2-07

Key words: jury trial, jurors, verdict, guilt, acquittal

Full text at PDF, 647Kb. Language: Russian.

Altai State University (Barnaul, Russia)
E-mail: DudkoNA@yandex.ru

Altai Territory Administration Committee for the Finance, Tax and Credit Policy (Barnaul, Russia)
E-mail: aleksandr-kamnev@mail.ru


Print Edition of "Izvestiya of Altai State University" © 1996-2017 Altai State University.
All rights reserved. Any of parts of a journal or edition as a whole cannot be reprinted without the written sanction of the authors or publisher. On purchase of a journal to address to ASU publishing house:
Altai State University. 656049, 66 Dimitrova street, Barnaul, Russia. Telephone + 7 (3852) 366351.